Key Takeaways:
– Ryan Murphy‘s Netflix series, Monster, continues to face criticism.
– The second season, focusing on the Menendez brothers’ case, has been disapproved by the brothers and their extended family.
– Despite backlash, Ryan Murphy defends his intent to shine a global spotlight on these cases.
– The public condemns Murphy for profiting from these tragic, real-life stories.
– A third season, focusing on notorious killer Ed Gein, is forthcoming.
Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan’s poignant Netflix series Monster, profiling history’s infamous criminals, remains under substantial public scrutiny. The second season, which recounts the notorious Menendez brothers’ story, has been met with notable disapproval from the brothers themselves.
A Word from The Menendez Brothers
Residing in the Richard J. Donovan Correctional Facility, the Menendez brothers haven’t held back from voicing their objections to the series. Erik Menendez took issue with the show’s portrayal of him and his brother Lyle Menendez. His protest, shared by his wife, Tammi Menendez, suggested that the series creators may have intentionally misrepresented the facts of their lives.
Murphy’s Response to Criticism
Nevertheless, Murphy has steadfastly defended his series. He even suggested that he should be receiving appreciation rather than reproach from the Menendez brothers. He insisted that his series had managed to reignite interest in their story, not only nationwide but across the globe.
Focusing on the angry responses regarding the series, he acknowledged to The Hollywood Reporter that he and his co-creator Brennan created exactly what they set out to do. He recognized that his portrayal might not be met with approval by the brothers or their associates. He suggested that many have offered to help them due to the renewed attention their case has received because of the series.
Public Reaction to Murphy’s Remarks
However, Murphy’s comments have stirred a whirlwind of controversy among the public. Several criticisms have sprung up accusing him of profiting from other people’s painful narratives while crediting himself for creating awareness around these stories. Users on social media platforms have expressed resentment over his comments, with some even suggesting legal action against him.
Another Round of Criticism for Monster
The Menendez brothers’ story is not the first time Murphy has faced a public backlash. He received similar criticism after the release of Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story. Families of Dahmer’s victims blamed him for sensationalizing the story and creating further trauma without considering their involvement.
More Monster Tales
Despite the escalating backlash and heated discussion, Murphy is unswerving in his commitment to narrating these stories. He has announced the third season of Monster, set to highlight the terror of infamous criminal Ed Gein with Charlie Hunnam marques the villain.
Though facing considerable criticism, Murphy’s Monster series remains available on Netflix to viewers intrigued by the severe and cruel acts of some of history’s most notorious criminals. His undeterred commitment to keep dwelling into these dark stories — despite the backlash — suggests there will be more tales of monsters from the annals of crime history to watch out for.
In conclusion, the debate around tasteful exploitation of real-life stories for entertainment continues to be a hot topic in Hollywood. As for Murphy, it seems controversy is a price he is willing to pay to bring to light the stories of these notorious figures.
