Key Takeaways:
- Hans Zimmer’s score for Dune: Part 2 was disqualified from the Original Score Oscar category due to excessive use of pre-existing music.
- The score reused more than 20% of themes from Dune (2021), violating Academy rules.
- Zimmer called the rule “stupid” and believes both Dune films are part of one story arc.
- The score is eligible for other major awards, including BAFTA, Critics Choice, and the Golden Globes.
- Daniel Blumberg won the Oscar for The Brutalist, which was considered the best score of 2024.
“Dune: Part 2” Score Ditched by Oscars Over “Stupid” Rule
Hans Zimmer’s hit score for Dune: Part 2 just got a shocking snub at the Oscars. Despite being a top contender, it didn’t make the cut for Best Original Score. Why? Because it broke one of the Academy’s rules.
The Music Rule That Backfired
The Oscars have strict rules about how much music from previous films can be reused in sequels. The limit is 20% of pre-existing themes. Zimmer crossed that line in Dune: Part 2. The Academy said his score was too similar to his work on the first Dune film. They ruled it ineligible for the Oscar.
Zimmer’s Frustration
Zimmer, who won an Oscar for Dune in 2021, isn’t happy about the snub. He called the rule “stupid.” “How can it be a sore point? It’s just such a stupid point,” he said. Zimmer believes the two Dune films are one story, not just sequels. He argues that reusing themes makes sense because the story continues. “Was I supposed to take away all the character themes and write new ones? It’s just a stupid rule,” he said.
The Academy’s Strict Guideline
The rule is clear: in sequels and franchises, no more than 20% of the score can be reused from earlier films. Zimmer’s score for Dune: Part 2 went over that limit. The Academy’s guidelines aim to encourage originality, but Zimmer feels this rule doesn’t fit all situations, especially for stories meant to be told in parts.
Other Awards Still in Sight
Just because Dune: Part 2 missed out on the Oscars doesn’t mean Zimmer is out of the race. His score is still eligible for the BAFTA Awards, Critics Choice Awards, Grammys, and the Golden Globes. In fact, he already won the Golden Globe for Best Original Score, proving his work is still highly acclaimed.
A Deserved Win for Another Composer
Zimmer’s disqualification opened the door for another composer to shine. Daniel Blumberg won the Oscar for his work on The Brutalist. Many critics agree that Blumberg’s score was the best of 2024 and well-deserved. It’s a reminder that competition in Hollywood is fierce, and sometimes unexpected twists change the game.
Moving Forward
Zimmer’s fans need not worry. He’s already teasing Dune: Messiah, the next chapter in the Dune saga. “Better luck next time,” he seems to say, but he also joked about being careful with “pre-existing themes.” With Zimmer’s talent and dedication, we can expect another epic score that will wow audiences and awards committees alike.
In the end, this snub doesn’t take away from Zimmer’s legacy or the brilliance of his Dune: Part 2 score. He continues to be one of the most celebrated composers in Hollywood, and his music remains unforgettable.
