Key Takeaways:
– Kevin Costner has alleged Taylor Sheridan of ‘borrowing' a plot from Yellowstone.
– This charge comes amidst the anticipation of Horizon: An American Saga's release.
– Sheridan acknowledged he draws inspiration from multiple sources.
– Sheridan and Costner have shared a tense relationship.
– Horizon: An American Saga's upcoming release could impact Yellowstone's ongoing popularity.
Kevin Costner's Accusations against Sheridan
Hollywood is known for its pattern of remodeling, recreating, and repackaging ideas. In a captivating twist, Kevin Costner, famous for his role as John Dutton in Yellowstone, has accused Taylor Sheridan of copying a storyline from the popular show. This revelation may come as a surprise to some, as Sheridan had openly acknowledged that he gets his inspiration from multiple sources.
Costner's upcoming movie, Horizon: An American Saga, shares a certain rugged wilderness essence similar to that of Sheridan's 1883. It's hardly surprising, then, that Costner suggested at Cannes that his American frontier story could have inspired the creator of Yellowstone.
Costner and Sheridan Share an Uncertain Relationship
Costner and Sheridan have reportedly been at odds for over a year, particularly in the wake of one of Yellowstone's spin-offs. As Horizon: An American Saga gears up for its 2024 release, Costner has opened a dialogue about possible shared plotlines between his film and Sheridan's 1883 series. This action stokes the existing speculation that Yellowstone may have pulled inspiration from other Westerns.
But even more intriguingly, Costner mentioned that he and Jon Baird, co-writer of Horizon: An American Saga, forwarded their script to Sheridan when the Yellowstone creator needed writers for the second season. Upon acknowledging the similarities between his film and Sheridan's 1883, Costner remarked that only Sheridan can admit if he borrowed anything.
In an industry teeming with adaptations, sequels, and reboots, borrowing ideas isn't a novel concept. So is it mere influence or deliberate copying? Only time can provide a verdict.
Sheridan's Inspirations and the Impact on His Work
Earlier, Sheridan confessed to deriving ideas from an array of places. He admitted being influenced by the Coen Brothers and others during an open-hearted chat with the Motion Picture Association. He even quoted a renowned director who once stated that all directors are akin to ‘thieves'. This candid confession puts a spotlight on Yellowstone's creative process and puts weight behind Costner's allegations. But it still remains uncertain whether this amounts to Sheridan blatantly copying elements from Costner's project or is just a case of two creative minds exploring identical themes and historic periods.
Waiting with Bated Breath for Horizon: An American Saga's Release
The release of Horizon: An American Saga will undoubtedly have repercussions on Yellowstone, particularly given the pending second part of the final season. The debate over creative ownership in Hollywood isn't new. We can only hope that the shared love for Western storytelling between Costner and Sheridan brings them together, rather than pushing them apart.
It's important to note that allegations are allegations, not definite truths. The audience can now only eagerly watch as the narrative unfolds, both on and off-screen. Meanwhile, fans can continue to enjoy Yellowstone, now streaming on Peacock.
