We Were Liars Season 2: Cast, Story, Casting Directors, and Everything We Know
Amazon Prime Video’s We Were Liars is officially returning for a second season, bringing audiences back into the wealthy, complicated, and secret-filled world of the Sinclair family.
Based on E. Lockhart’s bestselling young adult novel of the same name, We Were Liars combines psychological mystery, family drama, romance, and tragedy against the picturesque backdrop of a private island. After premiering in June 2025, the series earned a second-season renewal and is expanding its ensemble with several new and returning cast members.
For actors, filmmakers, and fans following the production, here is everything you need to know about We Were Liars, including the story, Season 2 cast, filming locations, casting directors, and potential casting opportunities.
What Is We Were Liars?
We Were Liars is an American psychological thriller and family drama based on E. Lockhart’s 2014 novel.
The story centers on the wealthy Sinclair family, whose seemingly perfect summers on their private Beechwood Island conceal family conflicts, romantic complications, privilege, resentment, and devastating secrets.
At the center of the story is Cadence “Cady” Sinclair Eastman, played by Emily Alyn Lind. Cadence is the eldest grandchild of family patriarch Harris Sinclair and spends her summers with a close-knit group known as the Liars.
The group consists of Cadence, Johnny Sinclair Dennis, Mirren Sinclair Sheffield, and Gat Patil.
After a mysterious accident leaves Cadence with memory loss, she returns to Beechwood determined to discover what happened during the summer she cannot remember. The deeper she investigates, the more painful the truth becomes.
What Happens in We Were Liars Season 1?
The first season of We Were Liars consists of eight episodes and follows Cadence as she attempts to reconstruct the events surrounding her accident.
Her investigation unfolds alongside flashbacks revealing growing tensions within the Sinclair family.
Family patriarch Harris Sinclair uses his wealth and inheritance as leverage over his daughters Penny, Carrie, and Bess. Meanwhile, the younger generation increasingly struggles with the expectations, privilege, and dysfunction surrounding the family.
Cadence’s relationship with Gat also becomes central to the story. Their romance develops while Gat challenges the Sinclair family’s attitudes toward wealth, privilege, and belonging.
Everything eventually culminates in a devastating revelation involving the Liars and a fire at the family’s Clairmont house. The Season 1 finale fundamentally changes Cadence’s understanding of the previous summer and gives new meaning to the events audiences witnessed throughout the season.
We Were Liars Season 2 Is Official
Prime Video renewed We Were Liars for a second season in September 2025.
The renewal allows the television adaptation to expand beyond the central mystery explored during its first season and dig deeper into the history of the Sinclair family.
Season 2 is significantly expanding the show’s ensemble, including actors portraying younger versions of several established Sinclair family members.
What Will We Were Liars Season 2 Be About?
The expanding cast provides an important clue about where We Were Liars Season 2 could take the story.
E. Lockhart followed We Were Liars with the prequel novel Family of Liars, which explores an earlier generation of the Sinclair family.
Season 2 includes younger versions of major characters such as Harris Sinclair, Tipper Sinclair, Carrie Sinclair, Penny Sinclair, and Bess Sinclair.
This opens the door for the series to explore the relationships, betrayals, family expectations, and long-held secrets that shaped the Sinclairs before the events involving Cadence and the Liars.
Who Is in the We Were Liars Cast?
Emily Alyn Lind leads We Were Liars as Cadence “Cady” Sinclair Eastman.
The main cast includes:
- Emily Alyn Lind as Cadence “Cady” Sinclair Eastman
- Caitlin FitzGerald as Penny Sinclair
- Mamie Gummer as Carrie Sinclair
- Candice King as Bess Sinclair
- Rahul Kohli as Ed Patil
- Shubham Maheshwari as Gat Patil
- Esther McGregor as Mirren Sinclair Sheffield
- Joseph Zada as Johnny Sinclair Dennis
- David Morse as Harris Sinclair
The supporting ensemble further expands the Sinclair family and the people connected to their summers on Beechwood Island.
We Were Liars Season 2 Cast
Several performers are joining or expanding their roles for We Were Liars Season 2.
Josh Dallas joins the series as a younger version of Harris Sinclair, the family patriarch portrayed by David Morse in the primary timeline.
Peyton List plays a younger Tipper Taft Sinclair, Harris’ wife and the matriarch of the Sinclair family.
Other Season 2 cast members include:
- Madison Wolfe as teenage Bess Sinclair
- Parker Lapaine as teenage Carrie Sinclair
- Elysia Roorbach as teenage Penny Sinclair
- Costa D’Angelo as Pfeff
- Dempsey Bryk as Ebon
Bryk appeared in a recurring capacity during the first season before being promoted to series regular for Season 2.
More New Cast Members Join We Were Liars Season 2
The We Were Liars Season 2 ensemble continues to grow.
Additional recurring performers joining the second season include:
- Riley Voelkel
- Madeleine Arthur
- Jaelynn Thora Brooks
- Layla Douglas
- Callan Potter
- Aidan Shaw
- Shaun Sipos
- Brendon Tremblay
The expanded cast reinforces the multigenerational direction of the series as the story explores more characters connected to the Sinclair family.
Who Are the Casting Directors for We Were Liars?
Casting is essential to We Were Liars, particularly because the series depends on performers who can convincingly portray multiple generations of the Sinclair family and navigate its mixture of romance, mystery, privilege, grief, and complicated family relationships.
Andrea Bunker and Deanna Brigidi are among the casting professionals associated with We Were Liars.
Andrea Bunker is a casting director and casting department professional whose credits include We Were Liars, Big Little Lies, and Off Campus. Her experience includes character-driven television projects requiring carefully assembled ensembles.
Deanna Brigidi is a casting director and casting department professional with experience across film and television. Her work contributes to finding performers who can meet the specific character, chemistry, and storytelling requirements of a production.
Hennessey Casting is also one of the casting teams involved with We Were Liars. The company’s involvement adds another important component to the production’s talent search and casting process.
With Season 2 expanding the story across different generations and introducing numerous new characters, casting remains an especially important part of building the world of We Were Liars.
Prime Video “We Were Liars” Season 2 Casting Call for Coroners
Female Coroner for “We Were Liars” Season 2
Job Description
“We Were Liars” Season 2 is seeking a female background performer to portray a coroner in the TV series. This background acting opportunity is looking for talent who can naturally fit into a 1990s-era morgue environment and convincingly portray a professional coroner. New faces and performers with previous background acting experience are welcome.
Job Responsibilities
- Portray a coroner in a 1990s-era morgue scene.
- Perform naturally within a medical and investigative setting.
- Follow direction from the production team during filming.
- Maintain appropriate character behavior and professionalism on set.
Requirements
- Female talent, ages 25–65.
- Must be comfortable portraying a coroner in a morgue environment.
- Open to union and non-union performers.
- Must be able to work in the Halifax Regional Municipality, Nova Scotia.
Compensation
- ACTRA background rates apply for union performers.
- Non-union rate: $16.75.
Prime Video “We Were Liars” Season 2 Casting Call for Wealthy Father
We Were Liars Season 2 – Wealthy Father
Job Description
“We Were Liars” Season 2 is seeking a male background actor to portray a wealthy father in a 1999-era scene. This TV series background role calls for a sophisticated, affluent appearance with a Southern European or Mediterranean look. Casting is open to new faces and performers who have not previously appeared as present-day or Season 1 background talent.
Job Responsibilities
- Portray a wealthy father in a 1999-era scene.
- Bring an authentic, polished, and affluent presence to the role.
- Follow direction from the production team throughout filming.
- Maintain character and continuity during potentially long shoot days.
- Arrive prepared for a full day of filming.
Requirements
- Male talent, late 30s to early 50s.
- Southern European or Mediterranean appearance.
- Dark or salt-and-pepper hair.
- Olive-leaning skin tone.
- Must be a Nova Scotia resident and legally eligible to work in Canada.
- Must have reliable transportation to the filming location in the Halifax Regional Municipality.
- Must be available for a full shoot day.
- New faces and eligible 1999-era background performers are encouraged to apply.
Compensation
- ACTRA background rates apply for union performers.
- Non-union rate: $16.75.
“We Were Liars” Season 2 Casting Call for New Actor
New Actor Roles for Television Series
Job Description
A television series is seeking new actors for upcoming roles filming in the Halifax Regional Municipality and Chester & Lunenburg, Nova Scotia. This casting opportunity is open to union performers who have not previously worked on the production, including background roles. Selected talent will participate in professional television production scenes throughout the upcoming filming period.
Job Responsibilities
- Perform an assigned character role in the television series.
- Follow direction from the director and production team.
- Maintain character continuity throughout filming.
- Arrive prepared and maintain professional on-set conduct.
- Participate in filming within the designated Nova Scotia production locations.
Requirements
- Must be a new performer to the production.
- Talent who have previously worked on the series, including as background actors, should not apply.
- Must be available to work in the Halifax Regional Municipality or Chester & Lunenburg, Nova Scotia.
- Must meet the specific character requirements for the selected role.
Compensation
- ACTRA rates apply.
“We Were Liars” Season 2 Casting Call for Female Coroner
Female Coroner for “We Were Liars” Season 2
Job Description
“We Were Liars” Season 2 is seeking a female background performer to portray a coroner in a 1999-era morgue scene. This television background acting opportunity is ideal for talent who are comfortable working around simulated death, morgue environments, and cold stainless-steel settings. New faces and eligible 1999-era background performers are welcome.
Job Responsibilities
- Portray a professional coroner in a 1999-era scene.
- Perform naturally in an interior morgue environment.
- Remain comfortable around simulated death and medical-themed set elements.
- Follow direction from the production team throughout filming.
- Maintain character, continuity, and professionalism during a potentially long shoot day.
Requirements
- Female talent, ages 25–65.
- Must be comfortable portraying a coroner in a morgue setting.
- Must be a Nova Scotia resident and legally eligible to work in Canada.
- Must have reliable transportation to the filming location.
- Must be available for a full shoot day in the Halifax Regional Municipality.
- New faces and eligible 1999-era background performers are encouraged to apply.
Compensation
- ACTRA background rates apply for union performers.
- Non-union rate: $16.75.
Who Created We Were Liars?
We Were Liars was developed for television by Julie Plec and Carina Adly MacKenzie, who also serve as showrunners.
The series is based on the novel by E. Lockhart, who is also among the project’s executive producers.
Executive producers associated with the series include Julie Plec, Carina Adly MacKenzie, Emily Cummins, Brett Matthews, Pascal Verschooris, E. Lockhart, and Nzingha Stewart.
The production companies behind We Were Liars include Because Magic Whatever, My So-Called Company, Universal Television, and Amazon MGM Studios.
Where Was We Were Liars Filmed?
Although the Sinclair family spends its summers on the fictional Beechwood Island, We Were Liars has used Nova Scotia, Canada, to bring the coastal setting to life.
Principal photography for the first season began in June 2024, with filming taking place around Halifax and Lunenburg, Nova Scotia. Production was completed by late September 2024.
The coastal locations help establish the isolated, picturesque atmosphere that defines the series. Beaches, waterfront properties, boats, and secluded landscapes provide a striking contrast to the darker family drama unfolding throughout the story.
When Did We Were Liars Premiere?
We Were Liars premiered on Amazon Prime Video on June 18, 2025.
The first season consists of eight episodes and introduced audiences to Cadence, the Liars, and the mystery surrounding the Sinclair family.
The series found a significant audience after its release, reaching the No. 1 position among Prime Video’s Top 10 TV shows during its release month.
What We Were Liars Season 2 Means for Actors
Returning television productions can generate casting needs beyond their established principal cast.
Depending on production requirements, a series may seek supporting performers, day players, background actors, stand-ins, photo doubles, and other specialized talent.
We Were Liars has an especially broad story world involving multiple generations, different time periods, family gatherings, island residents, and supporting characters. The growing Season 2 ensemble demonstrates how the television adaptation is continuing to expand beyond the original group of characters.
Actors interested in We Were Liars casting calls should follow legitimate casting announcements and carefully review eligibility requirements before submitting.
What’s Next for We Were Liars?
Season 1 answered the mystery at the center of Cadence’s story, but the history of the Sinclair family leaves considerable territory for We Were Liars Season 2 to explore.
The addition of younger versions of Harris, Tipper, Penny, Carrie, and Bess creates new possibilities for multigenerational storytelling.
With Josh Dallas, Peyton List, Madison Wolfe, and several additional performers joining the ensemble, the next chapter can reveal more about how the Sinclair family became the deeply complicated dynasty audiences encountered in Season 1.
For viewers, that means more family secrets and mysteries to uncover. For entertainment professionals, We Were Liars remains a television production worth following as its second season moves forward.
Find We Were Liars Casting Calls on Project Casting
Looking for We Were Liars casting calls and similar television opportunities?
Project Casting connects actors, models, filmmakers, content creators, and entertainment professionals with casting calls, auditions, and production opportunities across television, movies, commercials, and digital media.
Stay updated on We Were Liars casting opportunities, upcoming TV auditions, background acting roles, and entertainment jobs.
Explore the latest opportunities and apply now on Project Casting.
