Key Takeaways:
• Yellowstone, featuring Kevin Costner, has been a popular series due to outstanding acting and thrilling storylines crafted by showrunner Taylor Sheridan.
• One viewer questions an apparent narrative discrepancy from season 1 where John Dutton allowed his son to die.
• Fan theories suggest that showrunner Taylor Sheridan might have included this dramatic scenario to increase viewer interest and prolong the series.
• Concerns over the unbalanced character attention and expansion of spin-offs have also been shared by fans.
• In defense of Sheridan, the season 1 incident carries weighty implications for Yellowstone's future episodes and plot development.
The Popularity of Yellowstone
Yellowstone, a gripping Wild West drama series starring Kevin Costner, has held viewers captivated over five successful seasons. Thanks to the stellar acting performances and the enthralling storylines laid out by showrunner Taylor Sheridan, the series has remained popular. Sheridan, known for his exceptional work on projects such as Sicario and Hell or High Water, expertly crafts and navigates complicated plotlines, earning him high acclaim.
An Issue in Narrative Consistency
Despite the praise for Yellowstone, a recent critique by a new viewer has brought up a concern about the narrative in the series. The observation, which involves a storyline from the first season, has split the fan base. Some fans are questioning the writing, while others are defending the showrunner's decisions.
In season 1, a key event surrounds the Dutton family attempting to recover their stolen cattle from the Broken Rock Reservation. In the midst of this, their eldest son, Lee, is shot by Robert Long, resulting in his death. Not long after this tragic event, John Dutton recovers his stolen cattle using his intellect.
A fan on Reddit raised issues, wondering why, if retrieving the cattle could have been executed with such ease, did John Dutton allow his son to die? This plot progression, according to some, does not establish Dutton as a compelling character but rather portrays him as a person using his son's death for further gains.
Fans Voice Concerns About Yellowstone's Storytelling
A series of complaints await showrunner Taylor Sheridan. From his guest role in the series as Travis Wheatley to the apparent imbalance in character development and the dilution of the storyline through various spin-offs. Some fans also feel that Sheridan has manipulated the plot to secure the series' renewal without considering the continuity and integrity of the plot, though many others believe that this controversial sequence laid an engaging foundation for the subsequent seasons.
Understanding The Bigger Implications
In defense of Sheridan's creative decisions, the death of Lee has vast repercussions that shape Yellowstone's narrative. This tragedy sparks off a cascade of plot developments, including a shift in relationship dynamics within the Dutton family, heightened tensions with the Broken Rock Indian Reservation, and an escalation in local politics. All these elements contribute to creating suspense-filled scenes that heighten the viewing experience.
Despite the critique, the undeniable success of Yellowstone underlines the strength and resilience of its plot and character development. Undoubtedly, opinions will continue to be divided as fans grapple with their interpretation of events versus the creator's intention.
For the ones eager to make their judgment, Yellowstone is available to stream on Peacock, fuboTV, Paramount Network, and Netflix. As the gripping story unwinds, we can expect more plot twists that will keep us on the edge of our seats.
