Austin Butler Reveals How He Fully Became His Character in Caught Stealing
Academy Award–nominated actor Austin Butler is known for disappearing into his roles — from Elvis Presley to gritty, transformative performances that push him emotionally and physically. But in Darren Aronofsky’s Caught Stealing, Butler faced a very different challenge: playing a character who looked a lot like himself, with nowhere to hide.
In a recent interview with Variety, Butler opened up about his preparation for the role of Hank, a former baseball player drifting through life after a series of bad decisions. What begins as a simple pet-sitting job quickly spirals into chaos, pulling Hank into a dangerous chase involving powerful groups willing to kill for what he unknowingly possesses.
While the story is intense, Butler’s approach to acting in Caught Stealing offers powerful lessons for aspiring actors — especially when it comes to realism, vulnerability, and staying connected to character.
Why Austin Butler Slept on Set to Prepare for the Role
One of the most talked-about details from Butler’s preparation is surprisingly simple: he slept overnight in Hank’s apartment — even though it was just a set.
According to Butler, spending a full night in the space helped him stop seeing it as a filming location and start feeling like it was home.
“For one night, I had the whole apartment to myself,” Butler said. “I played music, I danced around, and I ate Chinese food in there. It made me feel like I really lived there.”
That immersion went so far that Butler slept through the night and woke up to the crew arriving — while he was still in his underwear.
It wasn’t about method acting for spectacle. It was about tricking his brain into believing the environment.
“It made it feel like it wasn’t a set anymore,” he explained. “There are many things that conspire against you when you’re making a movie — the lights, the cameras, the missing ceiling. The more I can do to trick myself, the more important it is.”
Acting Lesson for Aspiring Actors
Great performances often come from small, practical choices. Creating emotional truth doesn’t always require big gestures — sometimes it’s as simple as living in the space long enough for it to feel real.
Playing a Character Without Disguise Felt More Vulnerable
Unlike many of Butler’s recent roles, Caught Stealing didn’t require wigs, prosthetics, or major physical transformations. That made the experience more intimidating.
For Butler, acting originally provided a form of protection.
“One of the reasons I got into acting in the first place was that I am very shy,” he said. “Getting to play characters let me put on this other skin and become this other person. That made me feel free.”
But playing someone closer to himself removed that shield.
“Playing a character that feels more like myself left me with nowhere to hide and made me feel vulnerable.”
Acting Lesson for Aspiring Actors
Some of the hardest roles aren’t the most dramatic — they’re the ones that feel personal. Vulnerability is often where the most honest performances live.
Why Judging Your Character Can Ruin a Performance
As Hank makes increasingly questionable choices, Butler admits there were moments when he struggled to sympathize with his character. But he quickly recognized that judging Hank would weaken the performance.
“Sometimes I’d go, ‘Man, I want to like Hank more. I want him to make better decisions,’” Butler said. “I almost started to feel the seeds of judgment for my character. And that’s dangerous.”
Instead, Butler focused on finding Hank’s humanity.
“So a lot of my journey was finding his good heart.”
This mindset aligns with one of the most important acting principles: characters don’t see themselves as villains. Every character believes they’re doing the best they can with what they have.
Acting Lesson for Aspiring Actors
Judging your character creates distance. Understanding them creates truth. Even flawed characters deserve empathy — especially from the actor playing them.
Why Caught Stealing Matters for Actors Watching From Home
Directed by Darren Aronofsky, Caught Stealing blends crime, chaos, and psychological tension — but for actors, the film is also a masterclass in grounded performance.
Butler’s preparation highlights key truths about acting:
- Immersion helps override distractions
- Vulnerability creates authenticity
- Judgment kills connection
- Belief turns sets into reality
Whether you’re preparing for your first audition or your next big role, Butler’s approach is a reminder that acting isn’t about pretending — it’s about believing.
Ready to Find Your Next Acting Opportunity?
Project Casting helps actors discover real casting calls, auditions, and roles in film, TV, commercials, and digital projects — all in one place.
