I Can Only Imagine 2 Casting Calls & Auditions in Nashville

Takeaways

• Inspiring Sequel – I Can Only Imagine 2 is the sequel to the hit 2018 faith-based film, continuing the inspirational true story of MercyMe lead singer Bart Millard​. The sequel will reportedly center on Bart’s song “Even If,” inspired by his son’s health struggles, promising another uplifting narrative of faith and hope​.
• Returning Cast & New Faces – Major cast members from the original are back. J. Michael Finley returns as Bart Millard, with Dennis Quaid reprising his role as Bart’s father Arthur and Trace Adkins as MercyMe’s manager, Scott Brickell​. The sequel also adds new talent, like Milo Ventimiglia joining the cast as Christian singer Tim Timmons​. Fans can likely expect other familiar faces (such as Madeline Carroll from the first film) to return, alongside exciting new characters.
• Casting in Nashville by Jenny Alison Casting – Jenny Alison Casting is leading the background actor casting in Nashville, Tennessee​. Filming is based in the Nashville area (Franklin, TN), so most roles are for local talent. If you’re in Middle Tennessee, this production offers great film job opportunities in the region.
• How to Apply – I Can Only Imagine 2 casting calls are open now on Project Casting’s job board (see official Project Casting posting – placeholder link). Aspiring actors can apply by submitting the required info (photos, contact, etc.) as instructed in each casting call. The casting process is quick – make sure to follow all directions and submit ASAP if you fit a role.
• Audition Tips for Extras – No prior experience is required for most background roles​, but professionalism is key. Be punctual, flexible, and ready for long shoot days. Always follow the casting instructions closely (e.g. email subject lines, required photos​) and be honest about your availability – many roles require full-day or multi-day commitments​. Showing reliability and a positive attitude will greatly boost your chances of landing a part.

What Is I Can Only Imagine 2 About?

The original I Can Only Imagine movie (2018) moved audiences with the true story behind the song of the same name. Now, I Can Only Imagine 2 aims to continue that journey with another inspiring chapter in Bart Millard’s life. While the exact plot is under wraps, early hints suggest the sequel will focus on MercyMe’s song “Even If.” Bart Millard has shared that his son’s chronic illness inspired the song, which deals with faith even when prayers seem unanswered​. This indicates the film will explore themes of hope amid hardship, much like its predecessor. Fans can expect a heartfelt story of perseverance, family, and the power of music to inspire – staying true to the uplifting tone that made the first film a hit.

Notably, I Can Only Imagine 2 is backed by the same team that made the original a success. It’s being produced in partnership with Lionsgate and Kingdom Story Company, ensuring the sequel has a strong creative foundation. With the original film grossing over $80 million and touching millions of viewers, the sequel carries high expectations to deliver another emotionally impactful experience. In short, I Can Only Imagine 2 is shaping up to be an inspiring, faith-driven drama that continues Bart Millard’s true story – one that many aspiring actors are excited to be part of as production gets underway.

Who Is in the Cast of I Can Only Imagine 2?

One big draw of this sequel is the return of key cast members from the original film. J. Michael Finley is set to reprise his role as Bart Millard, the lead singer of MercyMe, after his powerful performance in the first movie. Fans will remember Finley’s heartfelt portrayal of Bart, and he’s back to continue Bart’s story in Part 2​.

Veteran actor Dennis Quaid is also reportedly returning as Arthur Millard (Bart’s father)​. This is exciting news, as Quaid’s performance as the abusive father-turned-inspirational figure was central to the first film’s emotional punch. Even though Arthur’s story arc concluded in the original, it’s likely we’ll see him again in flashbacks or pivotal moments given Quaid’s involvement. Likewise, country star Trace Adkins will return as MercyMe’s manager, Scott Brickell, providing continuity as Bart’s mentor figure​.

In addition to the returning stars, I Can Only Imagine 2 is bringing in new faces. The most buzzed-about addition is Milo Ventimiglia, known from This Is Us and Gilmore Girls, who joins the cast to play Christian singer-songwriter Tim Timmons​. Ventimiglia’s casting suggests the sequel will introduce new characters in Bart’s life and musical journey. There are also rumors of other potential cast members – for example, some fans speculate that actress Madeline Carroll might return as Shannon (Bart’s love interest from the first film), though this has not been officially confirmed. We may also see the actors who portrayed Bart’s bandmates (and perhaps new actors playing industry figures or family members relevant to the “Even If” storyline).

Overall, the cast of I Can Only Imagine 2 is shaping up to blend the beloved original actors with some exciting new talent. This mix should create a sense of continuity for fans while also expanding the story with fresh dynamics. For anyone hoping to join the cast as a background actor, it’s thrilling to know you could be sharing scenes with such notable names on set.

Who Is Handling Casting for I Can Only Imagine 2?

Casting for I Can Only Imagine 2 – especially for background roles and smaller parts – is being handled by Jenny Alison Casting, a well-known casting company based in Nashville. If you’re an aspiring actor in the region, this is important information: Jenny Alison Casting (JAC) is the official extras casting director for the film. They are the team posting casting calls, reviewing submissions, and booking talent for all the background actors, stand-ins, and photo doubles needed on set. JAC has a strong reputation in the area and has cast for numerous film and TV projects, so the production is in experienced hands.

Because I Can Only Imagine 2 is filming in Nashville, the casting director is seeking local talent. “Local hire” is a term you’ll see often – meaning you must be able to work in the Nashville area without requiring travel or housing provided. Jenny Alison Casting’s notices explicitly state they are only accepting submissions from those able to work as locals in Tennessee​. This is standard for most productions; it keeps casting focused on actors who are readily available and nearby.

It’s also worth noting that Jenny Alison Casting posts these casting calls on various platforms – including their Facebook page and industry sites. However, Project Casting is one of the primary places where these calls are aggregated for easy access by actors. Each casting call listing will mention JAC and the location (e.g., “Jenny Alison Casting – Nashville, TN”) so you know it’s an official notice​. In short, if you see Jenny Alison Casting attached to an I Can Only Imagine 2 casting call, you’re looking at the real deal. Following JAC’s guidelines and updates is crucial to make sure your audition submission gets seen.

How Does the Casting Process Work?

If you’ve never applied for a casting call like this before, don’t worry – the casting process for I Can Only Imagine 2 is straightforward. Here’s a step-by-step look at how it typically works for background roles:

1. Casting Call Posted: Jenny Alison Casting releases a notice describing the role(s) they need. For example, they might post “Seeking Female, age 28–35, blonde hair, for a featured background role” – along with details like the filming dates, location, and pay rate. In fact, one recent casting call was looking for a “petite female, 18–25, with white-blonde hair” for a featured extra part. Each notice will outline the requirements (age, look, etc.) and shoot schedule (e.g. must be available all day, or on specific dates).
2. Submission by Email or Online: To apply, actors usually need to submit their information via email as instructed. The casting call will give an email address (for JAC it’s often a specific address like booking@…@jennyalisoncasting.com) or a link to apply. Follow the instructions to the letter. Typically, you’ll need to send: your name, age, height, location, cell number, clothing sizes, and 2-3 recent photos​. They may also tell you to use a specific subject line (e.g., “CHARLIE PD” for a photo double role​). These details help the casting team sort submissions quickly, so don’t skip any requested info.
3. Include Appropriate Photos: When submitting, make sure to attach recent, clear photos that show your current look. Casting calls often stress that photos should reflect how you look right now (hairstyle, facial hair, etc.), with no hats or filters. For instance, if the role calls for a certain hair color or style, ensure your photo showcases it accurately. The goal is to make it easy for the casting director to see that you match what they need.
4. Casting Review: The casting team (JAC) will review all the emails/applications. They are looking to match the description provided by the production and also assess professionalism. If you meet the criteria and your submission is complete, you’ll be in the running. They might reach out with follow-up questions, but typically for background work, they select a pool of candidates that fit and proceed to booking.
5. Booking Confirmation: If selected, you’ll get a booking email or call from the casting team with all the details. This will include your filming dates, call time (when you need to be on set), location, wardrobe notes, and any COVID or paperwork instructions. Background actors often have to bring certain wardrobe options (e.g., “church attire” or casual clothes, depending on the scene) and arrive early for check-in and possibly a quick costume/makeup adjustment.
6. On-Set Expectations: Once on set, you become part of the production for the day. You’ll check in with the AD or extras coordinator, and then it’s hurry-up-and-wait. Be prepared for long days. A typical extra booking is around 8–12 hours (with overtime if it goes longer)​. Stay flexible – scenes can go into evening or require you to return the next day if it’s a multi-day shoot​. While on set, you must follow directions carefully, hit your marks as a background performer, and maintain a professional demeanor at all times​. The casting process doesn’t end once you’re booked; showing up on time and doing the job well means JAC and the production will remember you positively for future projects too.

For I Can Only Imagine 2, the casting process is moving quickly because filming is already starting. Many of the casting calls note that filming will happen on specific dates in late April and early May. So if you see a role that fits you, apply immediately – decisions and bookings may be made within days (or even hours) of the call going out. Always double-check that you meet the requirements and availability before submitting, and then put your best foot forward in the application.

Filming Location – Where Is I Can Only Imagine 2 Being Filmed?

Nashville, Tennessee is the primary filming location for I Can Only Imagine 2. The production is shooting in the Nashville metro area – with specific scenes in nearby towns like Franklin, TN (just south of Nashville). In fact, one casting call specified the “Franklin, TN area” for filming and made it clear they’re only considering local hires. This confirms that Middle Tennessee is the hub of the movie’s production activities.

Nashville has a growing reputation as a filming destination, especially for faith-based and music-related projects, which makes it a fitting backdrop for this story. For locals, it means plenty of opportunities: the phrase “background actor casting Nashville” is exactly what’s happening here – a large-scale film is creating roles for people in the Nashville community. If you’re based in Nashville, you won’t need to travel far to be on set, and you’ll get to work in a familiar area. For the film, using Nashville locations could add authentic scenery (possibly standing in for other locations in the story, or perhaps depicting Nashville itself if the story involves the music industry there).

It’s worth noting that while Nashville is the main base, some parts of the film may shoot elsewhere. (For example, there was a stand-in casting call for scenes in Colorado, hinting at a few days of production out west.) However, the vast majority of extras casting is for Nashville, so that’s the place to be if you’re looking to join the fun. Whether filming on a Nashville soundstage, a local church, or a concert venue, being on set in Tennessee will be an exciting experience for those cast.

When Does Filming Start (or When Did It Start)?

Filming for I Can Only Imagine 2 is starting in Spring 2025 – in fact, it’s kicking off right around now. According to production announcements, principal photography was slated to begin in late April 2025​. Casting calls have reinforced this timeline. For instance, one of the background casting notices listed filming dates of April 28, 29, and 30, 2025​, requiring actors to be available all three days. This suggests that the cameras are rolling in the last week of April, and likely into May.

As of today, casting is in high gear and some shooting is already underway or imminent. If you’ve applied or plan to apply, be prepared for quick turnarounds. You might get contacted just a few days before your scene films (or even the day before for rush calls). The production schedule seems to be relatively tight – possibly aiming to wrap filming in Nashville within a few weeks. This makes sense if the movie is targeting a 2026 release (which some reports indicate).

For aspiring extras, knowing the film dates helps you plan: expect most of the I Can Only Imagine 2 background work to happen in late April through May 2025 in the Nashville area. Shooting days are often long (12+ hours) and can start early in the morning. Keep an eye on weather as well – spring in Tennessee can be unpredictable, but production will shoot rain or shine (scenes can move indoors if needed). The bottom line is that filming has started (or is about to start), so if you haven’t yet, now is the time to get your submission in for any open casting calls. Once filming concludes, the opportunity to be in this movie will be gone!

Where to Find I Can Only Imagine 2 Casting Calls and Auditions

All the latest casting calls and audition opportunities for I Can Only Imagine 2 can be found on Project Casting’s website. Project Casting is a central hub that has posted multiple job listings for this film – including calls for background actors, stand-ins, photo doubles, and more. To find them, simply visit the site and search for “I Can Only Imagine 2,” or navigate to the Tennessee casting calls section. Each listing will have “I Can Only Imagine 2” in the title, making them easy to spot. (For example: “‘I Can Only Imagine 2’ Casting Call for Background Actor – Jenny Alison Casting – Nashville, TN.”)

For convenience, here’s a direct link to the Project Casting job post for I Can Only Imagine 2 auditions: Project Casting – I Can Only Imagine 2 Casting Calls. On that page, you’ll see the details of the casting call and an “Apply Now” button. If you have a Project Casting account, you can submit your application through their system, which is often a simple process of sending your profile or filling in a form. Otherwise, the listing will include instructions (as discussed above) for emailing the casting director. Project Casting consolidates these notices, so you don’t have to hunt across multiple sites or social media pages.

In addition to Project Casting, casting calls might also be announced on Jenny Alison Casting’s social media (such as their Facebook page) and on regional casting call boards like The Southern Casting Call. However, Project Casting is keeping an updated list, and in many cases, they partner with the casting company to streamline applications. Always ensure the source is legitimate – the ones on Project Casting are vetted and often directly posted by the casting directors or their team.

Pro tip: Check Project Casting frequently or set up alerts for “film jobs Nashville” or “Nashville casting calls.” The I Can Only Imagine 2 listings have been updated regularly as new needs arise (for example, one day they might post for a concert crowd scene, another day for a stand-in, etc.). By keeping tabs on the Project Casting page, you won’t miss any new audition opportunities for the film. And of course, apply promptly when you see a role that fits you, because spots can fill up fast!

Audition Tips: How to Land a Role in I Can Only Imagine 2

Landing a background role (or any role) in I Can Only Imagine 2 comes down to preparation, professionalism, and a bit of persistence. Here are some top audition tips to help you stand out and secure that casting spot:

• Polish Your Application: First impressions matter, and your email or online application is your audition for a background role. Make sure you include everything requested – from your physical stats to wardrobe sizes – in a clear, organized manner. Double-check your contact info. A well-prepared submission shows you’re serious and detail-oriented.
• Use Recent, Clear Photos: Your photos should reflect exactly what you look like today. Avoid heavy filters or old snapshots. Simple, well-lit digital photos are perfect (a forward-facing headshot and a full-body shot in normal attire). If the casting call is looking for a specific look (e.g., blonde hair, or a certain style), consider dressing to accentuate that in your photos. For example, for a “concertgoer” extra role, you might wear casual concert-style clothing in one of your pictures. This isn’t a requirement, but it can help the casting team visualize you in the role.
• Be Honest and Upfront (Especially About Availability): One of the fastest ways to lose a role is to back out because of availability conflicts. If the casting call says “must be available all day on May 5th,” do not apply unless you can commit. Many I Can Only Imagine 2 extras roles require multi-day availability or very long days. If you have even a slight doubt (like a day-job conflict or an out-of-town trip), resolve it before you submit or consider waiting for a different role. On the flip side, if you are completely open, emphasize that! Mention in your email that you are “available for all listed dates and have a flexible schedule.” Casting directors love reliable talent who won’t flake.
• Respond Promptly to Calls/Emails: After you apply, be on the lookout for any reply. If Jenny Alison Casting reaches out with a question or to book you, respond as quickly as possible. Sometimes they may need a confirmation within hours. Keep an eye on your email (and spam folder just in case) and have your phone nearby. Prompt communication could make the difference in securing your spot, especially with the fast-moving schedule on this film.
• Bring the Right Attitude on Set: Treat the casting process professionally from start to finish. If you get booked, arrive on time (or early) for your call time. Bring any required items (IDs for paperwork, specific wardrobe pieces) as instructed. On set, be attentive and adaptable. There may be a lot of waiting, but stay focused – when it’s time to shoot, you should be ready to go. Follow the assistant directors’ and PAs’ instructions closely. Directors and crew appreciate extras who are alert and easy to work with​. A cheerful, cooperative attitude can even lead to you being featured more prominently or asked back for additional scenes.
• No Experience? No Problem: Remember that I Can Only Imagine 2 does not require previous acting experience for extras. So even if this would be your first time on a film set, you have a shot. Just make sure to educate yourself on set etiquette. For example, know that on set, “quiet on the set” means silence, don’t look at the camera unless instructed, and don’t approach the lead actors for autographs or photos. Showing you can fit into the on-set environment smoothly is part of what the casting team is looking for. If you act like a professional, you’ll be treated as one.
• Stay Flexible and Professional: Background filming can be unpredictable. You might be moved to a different role than you expected (e.g., they might ask some extras to act as concert attendees and later as churchgoers). Be open to adjustments. Also, be prepared for scenes that could involve a lot of retakes; patience is key. If you’re asked to come back an extra day because the schedule changed, and you can manage it, do it – that goodwill goes a long way with casting. Essentially, once you’re booked, continue to demonstrate reliability and professionalism; it could lead to more work, either on this production or others that Jenny Alison Casting works on in the future.

By following these tips, you’ll increase your chances of not only getting cast in I Can Only Imagine 2 but also having a successful and enjoyable experience on set. Many background actors use opportunities like this as a stepping stone – you’ll gain experience, build connections, and who knows, you might even spot yourself on the big screen when the movie comes out! Good luck, and break a leg with your audition for I Can Only Imagine 2.