Why How I Met Your Mother Fans Disagreed with the Show’s Unexpected Ending

Key Takeaways:

– Fans of How I Met Your Mother were disappointed by the series' unexpected ending.
– Cristin Milioti was left in tears after reading the ending.
– Despite criticism, some cast members defended the series finale.

A Surprise Ending for How I Met Your Mother

The popular TV sitcom, How I Met Your Mother, stirred up a passionate response from fans due to its unpredictable ending. Despite the show's initial charm, the unexpected finale left many fans frustrated. This series, which featured Josh Radnor as Ted Mosby, was a beloved narrative exploring Ted's journey to find true love and the characters who became his chosen family.

A Shocking Plot Twist

The series' narrative followed Ted Mosby as he approached his future children with the desire to share the story of how he met their mother. From the moment Ted first met Robin Scherbatsky, something sparked between them. The journey we all followed lasted 9 long years, and as the story unfolded, we were left with many clues about the identity of the mother.

But the plot thickened. In the final season, it was revealed that Cristin Milioti, who portrayed the mother, died of cancer after spending several happy years with Ted. This only added more fuel to the heated response from fans.

A Polarizing Love Story

Here's where the series stirred controversy. When Ted finally concluded his story, his kids encouraged him to pursue a relationship with Aunt Robin. However, this didn't sit well with many fans. They argued that after everything that had transpired, Ted and Robin weren't meant to be together.

The show's ending received mixed responses, even among the cast members. While Cobie Smulders, who played Robin Scherbatsky, supported the ending, Cristin Milioti confessed she was moved to tears when she first read it.

Tears and Controversies

Cristin Milioti's character passed away due to cancer, and the storyline led Ted back to Robin, reviving their old love story from the days of their first meeting. This sparked confusion, frustration, and even romantic flutters among the audience. For Milioti herself, it took some time to grapple with the story's sudden turn.

When Mothers Cry

In an emotional revelation, Milioti shared her initial reaction to the ending in an interview with Vulture: “I just burst into tears as soon as they told me.” Despite her shock, she gradually came to understand and appreciate the unpredictable dash of life reflected in the story. Both Milioti and Smulders applauded the creators for sticking to their original narrative regardless of how the audience might react.

A Legacy That Lives On

Despite the mixed reviews surrounding its conclusion, How I Met Your Mother continues to be a celebrated show with a rating of 8.3/10 on IMDB and 84% on Rotten Tomatoes. Fans can relive the highs and lows of Ted Mosby's love quest on Netflix. The series serves as an unforgettable depiction of love's complex, unexpected, and often, beautifully messy twists and turns.